basketballMichael Jordan1984 Star Basketball #101RC$32,50014 sold / 30dbaseballShohei Ohtani2018 Topps High Tek Baseball #PYTSORC$20,0003 sold / 30dfootballTom Brady2020 Donruss Optic Football #DT-4$7,6005 sold / 30dhockeyBobby Orr1966 Topps Hockey #35RC$3,7006 sold / 30dsoccerPele1958 Alifabolaget Soccer #635RC$20,00012 sold / 30dwrestlingHulk Hogan1985 Topps WWF Wrestling #16RC$24.0049 sold / 30dmmaJon Jones2009 Topps UFC #FA-JJ$1,6004 sold / 30dracingMax Verstappen2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #6 Refractor$6145 sold / 30dbasketballKobe Bryant1996 Topps Chrome Basketball #138 RefractorRC$20,1006 sold / 30dbaseballMickey Mantle1951 Bowman Baseball #253RC$15,00016 sold / 30dfootballAaron Rodgers2005 SP Authentic Football #252RC$4,5273 sold / 30dhockeyGordie Howe1951 Parkhurst Hockey #66RC$1,9605 sold / 30dsoccerPele1958 Editora Aquarela LTDA Brasil Campeao Mundial de Futebol Soccer #10 Blue Number Perforated$1,6007 sold / 30dwrestlingHulk Hogan1985 Topps WWF Wrestling #1RC$20.0039 sold / 30dmmaConor McGregor2013 Topps UFC Bloodlines #139RC$6007 sold / 30dracingLewis Hamilton2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #1 Refractor$6084 sold / 30dbasketballLebron James2003 Topps Chrome Basketball #111 RefractorRC$14,25019 sold / 30dbaseballWillie Mays1951 Bowman Baseball #305RC$9,00015 sold / 30dfootballTom Brady2000 Bowman Chrome Football #236RC$3,95079 sold / 30dhockeyMaurice Richard1951 Parkhurst Hockey #4RC$1,5485 sold / 30dsoccerCristiano Ronaldo2015 Panini Select Soccer #36 Blue$1,5916 sold / 30dwrestlingGable Steveson2022 Panini Prizm WWE Wrestling #23 Silver$15.003 sold / 30dmmaRonda Rousey2012 Topps Finest UFC #A-RRRC$5043 sold / 30dracingMax Verstappen2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #6$82.0021 sold / 30dbasketballMichael Jordan1984 Star Basketball #101RC$32,50014 sold / 30dbaseballShohei Ohtani2018 Topps High Tek Baseball #PYTSORC$20,0003 sold / 30dfootballTom Brady2020 Donruss Optic Football #DT-4$7,6005 sold / 30dhockeyBobby Orr1966 Topps Hockey #35RC$3,7006 sold / 30dsoccerPele1958 Alifabolaget Soccer #635RC$20,00012 sold / 30dwrestlingHulk Hogan1985 Topps WWF Wrestling #16RC$24.0049 sold / 30dmmaJon Jones2009 Topps UFC #FA-JJ$1,6004 sold / 30dracingMax Verstappen2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #6 Refractor$6145 sold / 30dbasketballKobe Bryant1996 Topps Chrome Basketball #138 RefractorRC$20,1006 sold / 30dbaseballMickey Mantle1951 Bowman Baseball #253RC$15,00016 sold / 30dfootballAaron Rodgers2005 SP Authentic Football #252RC$4,5273 sold / 30dhockeyGordie Howe1951 Parkhurst Hockey #66RC$1,9605 sold / 30dsoccerPele1958 Editora Aquarela LTDA Brasil Campeao Mundial de Futebol Soccer #10 Blue Number Perforated$1,6007 sold / 30dwrestlingHulk Hogan1985 Topps WWF Wrestling #1RC$20.0039 sold / 30dmmaConor McGregor2013 Topps UFC Bloodlines #139RC$6007 sold / 30dracingLewis Hamilton2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #1 Refractor$6084 sold / 30dbasketballLebron James2003 Topps Chrome Basketball #111 RefractorRC$14,25019 sold / 30dbaseballWillie Mays1951 Bowman Baseball #305RC$9,00015 sold / 30dfootballTom Brady2000 Bowman Chrome Football #236RC$3,95079 sold / 30dhockeyMaurice Richard1951 Parkhurst Hockey #4RC$1,5485 sold / 30dsoccerCristiano Ronaldo2015 Panini Select Soccer #36 Blue$1,5916 sold / 30dwrestlingGable Steveson2022 Panini Prizm WWE Wrestling #23 Silver$15.003 sold / 30dmmaRonda Rousey2012 Topps Finest UFC #A-RRRC$5043 sold / 30dracingMax Verstappen2020 Topps Chrome F1 Racing #6$82.0021 sold / 30d
CardSquad
CardSquadSports Cards
Create account
baseball#486
1958 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #486 All-Star sports card
Scan This Card with iPhone

Point your iPhone camera at this card to identify grade, centering and real-time market value.

All-Starbaseball

1958 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #486 All-Star

Willie Mays · 1958 Topps Baseball

How much is a 1958 Willie Mays card worth?

The 1958 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #486 All-Star is worth around $75.00 ungraded, based on 11 closed sales in the last 30 days.

Raw Estimated

$75.00

Average condition ungraded card

Recent Average

$537

Across verified closed sales

Recent High

$550

Strongest confirmed transaction

Recent Low

$512

Lowest confirmed transaction

Rank in set

#13

of 495 priced cards in 1958 Topps Baseball

Sales, last 30 days

11

Closed sales the estimate was drawn from

Estimates aggregated from completed closed sales. Card grade, centering condition, and autograph authentication can significantly influence individual sale prices.

Track Price Alerts for This Card

Receive instant notification when verified sales for this card close.

Historical Price Trend

No price history yet. This card's price is recorded daily from now on.

Card Specifications

Sport / League
Baseball
Player
Willie Mays
Release Year
1958
Card Set
1958 Topps Baseball
Manufacturer
Topps
Card Number
#486
Variation / Parallel
All-Star
Sales (Past 30 Days)
11

Where to Buy on eBay

eBay opens with that search already typed. Nothing is bought or tracked here.

More Cards from 1958 Topps Baseball

All 1958 Topps Baseball values →Full 1958 Topps Baseball checklist →

More Willie Mays Cards

Every Willie Mays card and its value →